A
sandwich table decorated for the filthy rich
In the early 1960s, a financial revolution was
initiated which, through loopholes, created today's paradise for the corrupt
and the criminal. In his book "Moneyland", Oliver Bullough shows how
money laundering in Estonia, trafficing in Asia, forest wreckage at Borneo and
foundations in the Netherlands are parts of the same ecosystem.
Probably,
few readers of this article have heard of Siegmund Warburg. Nevertheless, he
has more than most of us contributed to shaping the world during the post-war
era. This and much more you can learn from reading Oliver Bullough's book
"Moneyland: Why Thieves and Crooks
Now Rule The World & How to Take It Back" (Profile Books). As the subtitle
indicates, it is about a global shift of power, where the big winners are players
of doubtful background.
Bullough
is a freelance journalist and author who has mostly reported from the former
Soviet Union. "Moneyland", his third book,
released in the autumn of 2018, has received brilliant reviews in English-language
media. Recently the Sunday Times appointed it as the Business Book of the
Year. And for those who want to understand the world beyond President Trump's
twittering and what is happening with the Swedish Academy and the Nobel price,
"Moneyland" is a must.
According
to the author, the idea of the book was born in a toilet after the Majdan
insurgency in Ukraine 2014. Exclusive television screens in comfortable seating
height made him realize why things went wrong in many of the former Soviet
states. The answer was unrestrained corruption. The plant was owned by a
Ukrainian company owned by a British, owned by a foundation in Lichtenstein -
nowhere was the president's name specified. The ownership structure is a
standard template for how corrupt individuals all over the world hide illegal
assets.
Yanukovych
was not so much president as he was the leader of a criminal consortium
plundering the assets of the Ukrainian people as a business idea. He tumbled in
vulgar luxery that seems inevitable when doubtful taste meets abnormal wealth.
But Ukraine is just the first stop on a journey that takes us farther and
beyond into what Bullough describes as a virtual country where national
borders, laws, taxes and morals are overshadowed. A country where only the
richest can aspire to citizenship. Welcome to Moneyland! - the dark backyard of
globalization.
In
July 1944, the Allies negotiated a new financial system in Bretton Woods, USA.
According to the architects of the system, unregulated financial markets caused
the instability that preceded the takeover of Nazis and led to war. If future wars were to be avoided and the
democratic order is protected, capital must be regulated and free trade
encouraged, was their conclusion. The restrictions of Bretton Woods on
capital movements set limits to how rational it was to steal for corrupt
individuals - too much money was simply difficult to handle and spend.
However,
in the early 1960s, a financial revolution began to open the ports of Eldorado
for the corrupt and criminal. At the heart of this process, was Sigmund
Warburg, owner of the bank S G Warburg & Co. in the City of London (mentioned
in the introduction). He was one of actors in the intergovernmental bond market
during the interwar period. He saw the potential of the considerable amount of
unproductive dollars, known as euro banknotes or eurodollars, on accounts outside the United
States, mainly in Switzerland and City of London. The only problem was that the
United States had sole right to issue bonds in dollars under the Bretton Woods
agreement.
However,
Warburg employees succeeded in identifying a number of loopholes in the
regulatory framework, and in 1962 the first dollar bond was issued outside the
United States. These became known as eurobonds, today the world largest
financial product in terms of turnover. The
holding was anonymous as it was
not registered and the certificate was a piece of paper that could easily be
transferred from one country to another. The
international capital had blown their shackles and the basic foundation for Moneyland was
made. It meant a crack in Bretton Woods, which eventually undermined the
US's ability to maintain the system as its guarantor. 1973 definitely put an end to it. Since then, tha banking system of various countries have
competed in deregulations to attract the capital, that is increasingly ripping
across the world, in pursuit of returns - usually they show very little interest
in the origins of that capital.
Bretton
Woods was bypassed by the fact that the transactions in the bonds - despite
being registered on the London Stock Exchange - were transferred to a legally
undefined site, offshore as it was called. The Bank of England understood that a gold
mine was in progress and decided to overlook the actions of the procedure.
City's bankers then took on the concept and created the modern offshore
industry, the best ever tool for money laundering and tax evasion.
Offshore usually points to the Channel Islands, Guernsey, Jersey and Isle of
Man, as well as England's ancient crown colonies, Nevis, the Cayman Islands,
whose legislation was tailored to managing capital that for various reasons
fled from its homelands. Moneyland had found its structure.
Bulluogh
is an initiated and educational ciceron into the gloomy world of legal
loopholes that makes the planet a smorgasbord for the truly rich. In Moneyland,
they can buy citizenship and diplomatic status, register their ownership where
they do not get taxed and hide their assets from governments and transparency.
Bullough describes the luxury consumption of
corrupt authorities, which can not be described as anything less than
pathological, not least in contrast to the situation in their home countries.
Creativity knows no limits when Moneyland's financial engineers serve their
clients. A piquant example is the rich Chinese who pick up eggs from their
wives and allow paid surrogate mothers in Japan to become pregnant with these -
all to have children who are Japanese citizens who then can act as anchors for capital and
investment.
Globalization has made capital transnational
while laws remain national, according to Bullough, this asymmetry represents the engine of the
global "kleptomania economy". This relationship also makes this crime
almost untouchable - it may take months or years before an investigator gets an
answer to a simple ownership question from another jurisdiction and then the reviewed
assets have often moved elsewhere. It is no coincidence that the great
revelations in recent years have been made by activists and journalists who
through networks can coordinate their efforts globally.
Moneyland,
however, also offers protection against unwelcome scrutiny. An individual who
gets his business inspected can make use of Britain's notoriously hard
injunction laws relating to offenses, which reach far beyond the country's
borders. Bullough himself has been forced to renounce publications after legal threats.
But most vulnerable are the activists
and journalists who find themselves closest to the source of corruption -
abuse, prison and murder are common means when Moneyland protects their own.
The illegitimate
capital each year leaving Africa is estimated to amount to three times the total
aid to the continent. Every year about 3 billion dollars from developing
countries are embezzeled. 50 per cent of Russia's total wealth, is estimated to
be located abroad. These money could
have gone to healthcare, education and development. Instead, the greater part
is sucked up by the financial system of the West, which therby assists the
industrial robbery. Bullough's
hometown of London is in many ways the capital citiy of Moneyland. There,
illegitimate capital transforms into real estate in the luxury segment. There
are lawyers and auditors who know everything about money and money laundering. It
is from the City of London that the major parts of the offshore systems are
controlled.
There
is, however, an actor who strikes hard when irregularities in the financial
world are discovered, namely the United States. At the time of the financial crisis in 2008, the US Department of
Justice forced the Swiss banks to open their client registers, which ended the
country's infamous banking secrecy and its leading position as a trustee of
dirty capital. But the United States does not make the same demands on its own
states. This means that, among other things, Nevada and South Dakota, with
their purposeful (tax excempt) foundations, attract the money forced away from traditional
tax havens when the United States is increasing the pressure. The US is thus
well on its way to becoming the world's largest tax haven and hideout for stolen property.
Bullough is very clear
to point out that Moneyland is the result of pack behavior, driven by
mutual interests, and not by any conspiracy. On the one hand, we have the
individuals who systematically rob their homelands and constantly seek ways to
escape, hide and spend "their" money. On the other hand, we have
those who get rich by showing how to do. Together they constitute the world's
most profitable interest groups and they have billions of reasons to ensure the
existence of Moneyland.
The
grip of "Moneyland" as an allegory for the complex of seemingly
autonomous structures that allow for corruption is brilliant. Money laundering
in Estonia, trafficking in Asia, illegal logging on Borneo and foundations in
the Netherlands are seen as isolated phenomena, but Bullough shows that they
are parts of the same ecosystem and how Moneyland is the point of intersection
of the destiny of the world today. As
long as its fi nancial structures delivers, environmental crime and drug
trafficking will be an extremely profitable business. As long as corruption is
growing, the flow of refugees and asylum seekers will grow and terrorist
organizations have a safe recruitment base of bitter young men. The
institutionalized corruption erodes democracy and the rule of law throughout
the world, especially as kleptocracy needs the protection of an authoritarian
regime. And the capital accumulated in
Moneyland is used to buy influence and affect the political development of
democratic countries.
"Moneyland
explains so much," writes Bullough and refers to the concept. But it also
applies to the book. Let us hope that some publisher will ensure that even
Swedish readers get to know one of the most important publications of the year.
Gunnar Wiman Freelance writer understrecket@svd.se
Todde
Also check: http://axiom1b.blogspot.com/2018/12/greed-fraud-banks-accountants-attorneys.html